Prof. Dr. Nasoha Saabin

The government of Pakatan Rakyat does not last long in Perak. Datuk Seri Dr Zambry Abd Kadir of Barisan National took over the post of Menteri Besar and Datuk Seri Muhammad Nizar Jamaluddin of Pakatan Rakyat had to evacuate the seat. Datuk Nizar was rather reluctant to leave the post and the house of Menteri Besar. However, he finally surrendered. When he left the house and the office of Menteri Besar, the public thinks that the problem solved and Datuk Seri Nizar will drop his claim to be Menteri Besar. However, the stories did not end there. The claim to become Menteri Besar continues and the case brought to the court. Prior to that, there are several demonstrations and public outcry asking for general election in Perak. Recently the case was brought to the court and the court unanimously decided that Datuk Seri Zambry Abdul Kadir maintain as the Menteri Besar of Perak. Continue reading →

Would Hudud Laws be implemented in Malaysia? Many are of the opinion, the implementation of Hudud Laws cannot be done in Malaysia because Malaysia is a multiracial and multireligious society. Many Muslims believe that the implementation of Hudud Laws can only be done in Malaysia when all the Muslims in Malaysia have correct and strong faith or iman. However many PAS members have the opposite opinion. They believe Hudud Laws must be implemented in Malaysia now, regardless of whether Muslims in Malaysia have correct and strong iman or not. When will all the Muslims in Malaysia have the correct and strong iman? Is there any effort or work on the part of the Muslims or the Malaysia government to correct and strengthen the iman of all the Muslims in Malaysia? Is it true that when Muslims have weak iman, we cannot implement the Hudud Laws? When will be the time for Hudud Laws to be implemented in Malaysia? PAS promise to the Malaysians during their election campaign that they will implement Hudud laws if they are chosen to rule Malaysia. PAS promise once they are elected to rule Malaysia, they will make Malaysia as Negara Islam. Since PAS join DAP and PKR, the slogan of Negara Islam and Hudud Law have become weakened and now PAS decided to change their slogan to Negara Berkebajikan. PAS changed the slogan because they wanted to wins the vote of the non-Muslims. Since many years PAS was trying to win the general election with the slogan of Negara Islam and Hudud Laws but they failed and only manage to rule the state of Kelantan. Many PAS members are in the opinion that they can only win the general election and rule Malaysia if they changed their traditional slogan to Negara Berkebajikan. With the new slogan PAS is ready to work with DAP a party which is deadly against the concept of Negara Islam and Hudud Laws.
When Tun Dr Mahathir was the Prime Minister of Malaysia, he was in the opinion that Negara Islam proposed by PAS is not the true concept of Negara Islam as mention in the Quran but it is Negara Islam as perceived by the members of PAS. Negara Islam as proposed by PAS will only make the Laws of Hudud to be only applicable to the Muslims and not to the non-Muslims. According to Tun Dr Mahathir, Islam is a religion that promotes justice and wellbeing to the whole mankind and if Hudud Laws proposed by PAS are only applicable to the Muslims, and not to the non-Muslims, then the Laws is permeating injustice to the Muslims. As for example, in criminal cases when it involved between Muslims and non-Muslims, according to the Hudud Laws proposed by PAS, only the Muslims in the criminal cases are implicated with the Hudud Laws while the non-Muslims will be judged according to the civil laws. In other words, in case a Muslim is caught stealing, his or her hand will be amputated but when a non-Muslim is caught stealing, he or she will only be sentenced to imprisonment or with other forms of punishments. Tun Dr Mahathir argued, in case Hudud Laws as proposed by PAS being implemented in Malaysia, we will find more Malays (who are Muslims) will have their hands being amputated and while the non-Muslims will escape such punishment. According to Tun Dr Mahathir, this is injustice and according to him, whatever promotes injustice is not Islam. What Tun Dr Mahathir was trying to explain is that he is not against Hudud Laws if the laws are implemented according to the real teaching of Islam. Tun Dr Mahathir claims that PAS interpretation of Islam is not the real Islam. Although Tun Dr Mahathir did not agree with the Islam interpreted by PAS, yet until today, Tun Dr Mahathir has not come up with the correct interpretation of Islam that he claims to be the true Islam.
PAS members are so annoyed with Tun Dr Mahathir and to some PAS members they think Tun Dr Mahathir has become an apostate and they call him by the nickname of MahaFirun. PAS rule the state of Kelantan for nearly twenty years and during those twenty years of administration, PAS had failed to rule Kelantan with Islamic or Hudud Laws. During the time when Tun Dr Mahathir was the Prime Minister; PAS blamed Tun Dr Mahathir for not allowing them to establish Hudud Laws. But now, Tun Dr Mahathir had resigned as the Prime Minister of Malaysia since 2003 but still until today, Kelantan has not decided to establish Hudud Laws in Kelantan. Although outwardly PAS did not agree with Tun Dr Mahathir but by looking at their actions in Kelantan, it looks as if to a certain extent PAS agree with the opinion of Tun Dr Mahathir. Among the states in Malaysia, Kelantan has the highest percentage of peoples inflicted with the deadly and sexually related diseases of HIV and Kelantan has the highest rate of divorce and the highest rate of Muslims trying to change to other religions. What has gone wrong with the state of Kelantan under the rule of PAS? PAS is an Islamic party and the Menteri Besar of Kelantan is a Tuan Guru Nik Abdul Aziz, a well know religious cleric in Malaysia. All the PAS members respected him and some go to the extent of believing that Tuan Guru Nik Abdul Aziz would never makes any mistakes and that he is the lover of Allah. Many PAS members believe that whatever said by Tuan Guru must be true and need to be followed by all the members of PAS. Although rule by the so call religious person that represent the so call Islamic party, yet there are more peoples in Kelantan got infected with the deadly and sexually abused diseases of HIV. Many peoples in Kelantan entertain themselves with girls who were infected with AIDS in the neighborhood country of Thailand. Thailand is the neighbour of Kelantan and prostitution is a business openly operated in Thailand. Tuan Guru Nik Aziz must have failed in teaching the peoples of Kelantan on how to increase their iman and on how to prevent themselves from falling into the traps of Syaitan. Every week, Tuan Guru Nik Aziz teaches Islam to the peoples of Kelantan, and probably only a handful of them are benefitting from the lessons given by him, while the rest of the peoples of Kelantan are not benefitting from him at all. In case Hudud Laws are implemented to the Muslims in Kelantan, according to Tun Dr Mahathir, many will have to be killed by stoning them to death and hands being amputated.
I think neither PAS nor Tun Dr Mahathir knows how to implement Hudud Laws. Both parties are in the dark on how to implement Hudud Laws in Malaysia. Neither of them is against the Laws of Hudud. Both parties agree that Hudud laws are laws that come from Allah and we need to implement Hudud Laws but as according to Tun Dr Mahathir, we need to implement the Laws with justice or fairness to both Muslims and non-Muslims. Let me tell you and those who read this article that all the orders that come from Allah are meant only to those who have strong faith in Allah (beriman) and not to those who have no strong faith in Allah. Many of those who have recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah are not yet believers or Muslim or Mukmin. Many who recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah have only recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah on their mouth and the Great Kalimah Syahadah have not yet entered their heart. Only those who have recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah from their heart are called believers or Muslim or Mukmin. Generally many people have only recited the Great Kalimah with their mouth and not with their hearts and they are only regarded as to have entered Islam or ‘masuk Islam ‘or ‘orang Islam’ and certainly they are not Muslims or believers or Mukmin. Only Muslims or Mukmin would like to obey all the orders of Allah in the Quran. Allah is the only One that can place the Great Kalimah Syahadah into our heart and Allah will do that once He is pleased with us and Allah will be pleased with us when we have obeyed all the orders of Allah, starting with the First order of Allah. What is the First order of Allah? The First order of Allah is that one has to recite and fulfills the right of the Great Kalimah Syahadah. What is meant by the fulfillment of the right of Great Kalimah Syahadah? Enjoining good and forbidding evils and the greatest evils done by men is they do not want to accept the truth that there is no God except Allah and Muhammad is the Prophet of Allah and to enjoin good to these people is by inviting (Dakwah) them to accept and recite the Great Kalimah Syahadah. On the other hand the greatest evil done by those who have recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah is they do not fulfill the right of the Great Kalimah Syahadah and they do not perform five times obligatory prayers. Enjoining good to these people is by inviting them to do the work of Dakwah and to perform five times daily prayers.
Generally many of those who have recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah in the whole world are not fulfilling the right of the Great Kalimah Syahadah and Allah is not pleased with them and although they have recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah since they were young, yet the Great Kalimah still remains in their mouth and not in their heart. Many of those who have recited the Great Kalimah Syahadah are still orang Islam and not Muslim or Mukmin. Orang Islam would not be ready to accept the Hudud Laws and if they are given the choice, they will choose the civil laws instead of Hudud Laws. We can implement Hudud Laws in Malaysia by giving the criminals the choice to either choose Hudud or civil laws. Hudud Laws are for the believers or Muslim who choose in this world to be punished under Hudud laws so that they will not be punished in the hereafter. Orang Islam and the non-Muslims will certainly choose the civil laws because they have no fear of Allah and the punishment in the hereafter. In Malaysia we should have two courts that exercise Hudud and Civil Laws and the criminals should be given the choice to either be judged in the Civil or Hudud Court. In Islam there is no compulsion to follow the orders of Allah. Government should not force the peoples to become Muslims or to obey the orders of Allah. Government is only to encourage the peoples to become Muslims and to obey the orders of Allah and to provide the system that will encourage the peoples to embrace Islam and to obey the orders of Allah. Islam promotes justice and Allah will not require us to obey His orders that we cannot bear. In order to enable us to obey all the other orders of Allah, Allah has given us the First Order of Allah and if only orang Islam obey the First Order of Allah, and the other four Pillars of Islam (Rukun Islam), Allah will give them the strength of iman that will enable them to become Muslim or Mukmin. Once a person has become Muslim or Mukmin, he or she will be ready to be judged in the court that practice Hudud instead of Civil Laws because they have fear of Allah and the punishment in the hereafter. One interesting question; Would Haji Hadi or Tuan Guru Nik Aziz and all the PAS members who strongly vote for Hudud Laws will choose the court that practice Hudud Laws if in case they are involved in some criminal charges?
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
March 2012
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

In my opinion, these two parties are the same. The members of both parties are the Malays and all Malays are Muslims. They are like two groups of the same type of peoples that wear cloth of different colours. They are like two football teams that wear different jersey. One team is wearing blue and the other one is wearing green jersey. Both teams want to win the game and both want to be the champions. Umno and Pas are brothers and sisters in Islam, they are all Malays.Gerakan, and MCA are another teams consists of non-Muslims and all of them are Chinese.MIC and Makhal Sakti are two other teams consist of non-Muslims and all of them are Indians. PKR is another team consists of Malays, Chinese and Indians.

All the teams are contesting with one another and all of the teams want to become the champion. In democratic system, the team that is most popular will win the contest and become the champion. In order to become the most popular team in Malaysia, they cannot be alone. Pas will never become the most popular team because only Muslims like Pas and among the Muslims, some will like Umno. In Democratic system, Pas will never rule Malaysia as Pas will never becomes the most popular team if Pas remain alone. Similarly DAP will not becomes the most popular teams in case DAP stands on its own. In order to become the champion and to become the most popular group Pas must decide to join DAP, PKR to form Pakatan Rakyat and Pas must leave the image of Islam, and Pas should not use the name Islam.

In democratic system, the one that wins is not necessarily the best team that can discharge the best services. The one that is the most popular will win and Thaksin and his party although dislike by the business communities of Thailand because he has monopolized businesses in Thailand still wins because he and his party is the most popular in Thailand CLICK. In case Pas want to win and becomes popular in democratic system and rule Malaysia, Pas has to leave his Islamic image and becomes the party like Umno. Umno members are Muslims but they do not carry the Islamic image like Pas and their aim in joining Umno is not to elevate Islam but to elevate the Malays and also Islam. To those Malay Muslims who join Pas because they want to elevate Islam, they had better think twice. By joining, an Islamic party in democratic system does not elevate Islam. When Muslims do the pure and sincere work of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w then Islam will be elevated. Islam is pure and it needs pure and sincere work. Islam not elevated by having an Islamic party within a democratic system. The sincere Pas members who want to elevate Islam they should do the work of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w the way the Prophet s.a.w did instead of joining any political parties.

In order to win and rule Pas that has an Islamic image in a democratic system must be popular. An Islamic party in a democratic system wills never wins as many people dislike Islam and do not like to practice Islam even though they are Muslims. Many Muslims are only by names and they do not really like to practice Islam. Pas will only be popular among Muslims that like Islam and the number is less. Pas can become the most popular only in the states that have many Muslims that like Islam. Pas should not dream that they will ever-ruled Malaysia in democratic system. The only hope Pas has is to continue to rule Kelantan and Kedah but not Malaysia.

That is how a democratic system works; the most popular even they are evils and stupid will wins and rule. The leader of the most popular groups even though he or she is evil and stupid will becomes the Prime Minister or the President of the country. When Pas can never rule Malaysia how Pas will ever dream to establish an Islamic Laws in Malaysia. Only able to rule one or two states will not make Pas able to change the Federal Constitutions of Malaysia. The slogan that Pas used to have, that is to establish Malaysia as an Islamic state is only a dream. We can talk about many good dreams but dream will remain a dream and it can never become a reality.

Many Malays who join Pas because they want to elevate Islam, to established the orders of Allah in Malaysia, to established Hudud Laws in Malaysia and to establish all those related to Islam. I want these people to sit and think whether the nobles aims will ever be achieve by joining Pas. In case you truly believed that it would, you may continue to be in Pas and I wish you good luck.
However, in case you think the noble aims cannot be achieve by joining Pas then you had better use your times and energy to do the work of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w like the Prophet s.a.w did in your locality, making your mosque as your base. Using your local mosque as your base, you should visits the Muslims in your locality reminding them about Allah and the orders of Allah. To the Muslims you should ask them to do the work of dakwah and to perform five times daily solat with congregation in the mosque. You should also visit the non-Muslims in your locality, inviting them to enter Islam and to recite the Great Kalimah, there is no God except Allah and Muhammad is the Prophet of Allah. Detailed on how to do the work I have written in my other articles in this blog CLICK.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
March 2010
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

The deviant members of Umno, who were not satisfied with the way Umno works, originally set up Pas. They went out of Umno and set up a new party by the name of Pas. The founding members of Pas were not satisfied with Umno and set up a new party with the vision and mission, to set up a country that will uphold the laws of Allah. In other words, the founding members of Pas were consisting of young Muslims who want a country that uphold the laws of Allah, but were not sure on the ways to achieve the visions. The founding members of Pas were the same as the founding members of Umno. They were the same but were only different in their emotion about Islam. Pas members are more emotional about Islam than Umno members but they are the same. Both Pas and Umno members are Muslims with different emotion about Islam. Having different emotion about Islam does not make a person to become a better Muslim than the others. Muslims, who are more emotional about Islam, usually wear Muslims attires and talk loudly and openly about Islam. They talks loudly about Islam but in practice, both the Muslims with high and low emotion about Islam are the same. Both the actions of the members of Pas and Umno are the same and they only differ in their attires. Umno members usually wear Baju Melayu with songkok or western dress but Pas members wear attires similar to the Arabs. What a person wears does not indicates what is in his or her heart. What a person does indicates what is in their heart. Allah looks at a person heart and his or her actions and not what a person wears or talks. In my opinion, both the heart and the actions of the members of Pas and Umno are the same. Pas members only appear outwardly to be Islamic than Umno members are. Allah measures men according to what is in their heart and what their actions are.
Pas members are trying to set up a country that upholds the orders of Allah. The first order of Allah that Pas will uphold in case Pas is ruling Malaysia is to uphold the Laws of Hudud. Once upon a time, Pas members and their leaders were so vocal on the idea of establishing the laws of Hudud in Malaysia and that happen at a time when they were not having even a state to rules. After they have the state of Kelantan to rule in 1990, only then Pas leaders and their members knows and realized that it is not easy to establish Hudud Laws even in the state so call as Serambi Makah. Pas knows that Muslims in Kelantan are not ready to accept the Laws of Hudud. To establish the Laws of Hudud laws will only welcome trouble to Pas. Pas leaders had now realized that it is not easy to established Hudud Laws in Kelantan. In order to cover their own shortcoming and lack of understanding in establishing the laws, Pas keep pointing their finger to the Federal Government, which at that time was control by Umno. No one wants to admit their mistake, and so do Pas members and their leaders. It is unlikely that the Federal Government stops them from establishing the Laws of Hudud in Kelantan but Pas is the one who were reluctant to do so. In my opinion, what are in the hearts of Pas leaders is the same as what are in the hearts of Umno leaders. Both of them only want power and not so keen to establish the orders of Allah. Do Pas genuinely want to establish the orders of Allah? Pas is like Umno, both of them only want power. Pas members say they want power so that they can establish the orders of Allah and the first order of Allah they want to established is the Hudud Laws. After having power to rule Kelantan for more than two decades, the Laws of Hudud that Pas want to uphold is still in file. Now Pas is saying that they will only uphold the Laws of Hudud only if they are given power by the peoples to rule Malaysia. Can we trust Pas leaders that they will uphold the orders of Allah in Malaysia when they are in power or they will be same as Umno. Pas is not sincere in their promises. Pas is not to be trusted .They will never be able to uphold the laws of Allah in Malaysia when they are in power. Pas want Islam in their speeches but not in their actions. What are the action plans of Pas to make Malaysia a country that will uphold the orders of Allah, once they are in power? Pas has no action plans and surely, there will never be any actions taken by Pas to make Malaysia that will uphold the orders of Allah. It is only mere talks and the poor and illiterate yet emotional Muslims will become the supporter of Pas. In order to deceive the poor, non-educated yet emotional Muslims, Pas leaders wear Muslims attires and talk loudly about establishing the Laws of Hudud.
Umno leaders want to have power in order to eradicate poverty among Malays who are in general are all Muslims. Umno leaders want power so that this country will remain forever belongs to the Malays, the right owner of this land, Ketuanan Melayu. Umno aims in upholding the supremacy of the Malays, and are not pretending like Pas to establish the orders of Allah in Malaysia. Umno leaders and members are not emotional about Islam but they are more emotional about the Malay race and the survival of the Malays. Umno leaders argue that to uphold the supremacy of the Malays is to uphold the supremacy of Islam, as all Malays are Muslims. Pas in the other hand has a correct mission and vision but has no actions plans to materialize the vision and mission-to upholds the orders of Allah. Pas has neither the actions plans to uphold the orders of Allah and no action plans to uphold the supremacy of the Malays. With Pas, the Malays will lose both the supremacy of Islam and the supremacy of the Malays. Now as we see it, in order to gain power, Pas is willing to torn down the slogan of Negara Islam and is willing to have collaboration with DAP and PKR, the two parties that are against the establishments of the orders of Allah in Malaysia. What the Pas leaders have said previously, that their vision and mission is to establish the orders of Allah in Malaysia are only slogans and talks to deceive the poor, illiterate yet highly emotional Muslims? The movements of the world Tarikat group CLICK or Jemaah Tabligh in Malaysia has helps to increase the number of emotional Muslims in Malaysia, and thus help Pas to spread its influences and wins power. As the world Tarikat group spread its influence in Malaysia, Pas rather than Umno will have the advantage.
Umno has the vision and mission that Malays are forever in power in Malaysia and Umno has no slightest inclination toward upholding the orders of Allah in Malaysia. Other than making so many beautiful mosques in Malaysia, Umno hasn’t done so much effort to uphold the orders of Allah in Malaysia. Umno in principles is similar to all political parties in the world except it is a racial base party. All political parties in Malaysia except Pas and PKR are a racial base party and this entire racial base party join together to form Barisan National. All politicians in Malaysia are racists and the party base on race works well in Malaysia, as all peoples in Malaysia are racists. Racism is natural and all peoples are racist, unless people have strong faith or iman towards Allah. Allah will not installed strong Iman or faith towards Allah into the peoples heart unless everyone in Malaysia enter Islam and do the work of the Prophet saw. As it is now, the most suitable system to practice in Malaysia is racial base democracy. In case Pas really wants to uphold the orders of Allah in Malaysia, it is not by establishing political party with only names and colours of Islam but all Pas members must do the work of Prophet Muhammad saw CLICK. Orders of Allah cannot be established via political movements but via the work of Prophet Muhammad saw, through the ways Prophet Muhammad saw and with sacrifices as that had been done by the Prophet saw and his companions. When we want to establish the orders of Allah, via political movements, it is a mere waste of energy and time. No Prophets as well as our Prophets have never established political parties like what Pas is doing to establish the orders of Allah. Never in history, does Allah make the orders of Allah to be alive via political parties. Pas leaders and members are only dreaming to establish the orders of Allah via political party. It will never happen even for thousands of years. Allah has made the orders of Allah to be alive only via the work of Prophet Muhammad saw and nothing else. When men disobeyed Allah, Allah sent Prophets and all these Prophets did the work of Prophet CLICK and not involving themselves like Tuan Guru Nik Aziz and all the Pas members do in political parties. Tuan Guru Nik Aziz should stop telling the public that Umno are against the effort of establishing the orders of Allah and they are Jahilliah. Umno leaders and members are telling the truth and they are telling the people what they can do. Umno knows that the orders of Allah will not be made alive via Umno but via the true work of Prophet Muhammad saw. Tabligh groupCLICK claim they are doing the work of Prophet but they are not and Pas claim Islam will be alive via political parties and it is a mere lie.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
February 2011
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

Daulat Tuanku !
Ampun Tuanku, salah dan silap pembicaraan patek harap diampun.
Your Majesty is the guardian to all Malays and others who regard your Majesty as their ruler. The Malays in Malaysia regard DYMM Tuanku as their ruler. Malays are known to be obedient to their rulers as they regard them as their leaders.
In order for any society to live in peace and harmony they must have a leader. The leaders to all the Malays are their rulers and the rulers are in fact their Ulul-Amri @ Amir @ Imam. As in a congregational prayer, the followers are responsible to follow each and every movement of the imam. As the imam moves, the followers also follow the same movement. The followers cannot make any movement ahead of their imam and in case the followers are ahead of the imam, the prayer of the followers will not be regarded as a congregational prayer or in another word become nullified. When the imam makes a mistake, it becomes obligatory upon the followers to correct him. Allah has ordered the followers to correct the imam in a polite manner. Allah has ordered the followers of the congregational prayer to say “Subhanallah”. When we correct the imam, our intention is not to correct the imam but only to obey the orders of Allah and to please Him alone. Allah teaches us to be polite in reminding our Imam. Similarly, when our leaders do make mistakes, Allah orders us to remind them in a polite manner.
DYMM Tuanku is our only leader and the leader of citizens of Malaysia. DYMM Tuanku has delegated the power to govern this blessed country to the citizens and the citizens in turn, through a democratic system, elected leaders to represent them in the Parliament. The leader of the political party that wins majority of the parliamentary seats will be made the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister however is not the Ulul-Amri. The Ulul-Amri is still the DYMM Tuanku who is elected from the Conference of Rulers of Malaysia. Whoever among the rulers appointed as the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong is the Ulul-Amri ( Amir ) of Malaysia.
DYMM Tuanku is our supreme Amir. At any time there should not be two Amirs. It is the order of Allah SWT that there should only be one Amir that rules and leads at any one time. When we have two Amirs, ‘fitnah’ will prevails.
Fitnah means we will have chaos and among Muslims there will be antagonism. Muslims will in the end kill each other, and there will be no love and peace between them. When some Muslims during the time of Khalifah Uthman may Allah be pleased with him wanted to kill him, Hazrat Uthman had advised the Muslims not to do so; and he had warned them that if they didn’t obey his order as their legitimate Amir but instead, obey the orders of another Amir, there will be chaos instead of love and peace between the Muslims after his death.
History had witnessed the truth of what had been said by Hazrat Uthman prior to his death. After Hazrat Uthman was killed, Muslims until now no longer experience peace and harmony between them. The first question Hazrat Umar asked the Muslims when he was stabbed was who has stabbed me? When the people told him that the one who has stabbed him was a non-Muslim, he was greatly relieved. When a Muslim kills a Muslim and the Muslim who was killed is the Amir of the Muslims, then fitnah will come to the Muslims. The Muslims cannot have more than one Amir at any one time to lead them.
In Malaysia at this time, there should be only one Amir and the only Amir is DYMM Tuanku. DYMM Tuanku is the real Amir of Malaysia. DYMM Tuanku must take charge of Malaysia particularly during chaos. DYMM Tuanku must take charge particularly when those whom DYMM Tuanku has empowered to execute laws and orders have failed to do so. During chaotic and turbulent times, it become the incumbent duty upon DYMM Tuanku to establish peace and harmony in this country.
When those politicians whom DYMM Tuanku have entrusted to establish law and orders have failed to do so, it becomes the responsibility of DYMM Tuanku to take back the power and rule this country. Because of politics, the Malays are not united and in the name of establishing justice in Malaysia many lies have been made. Many politicians are no longer genuine in their struggles to establish Malaysia as a country where the citizens can live in peace and harmony. Many Politicians have turn politics into a mean of enriching themselves with wealth and power. Many politicians are more interested in using the power entrusted to them, to make their families and themselves richer. Many politicians are even willing to deny the rights of the Malays, only because they want to gain the political supports from the Chinese and the Indians. When politicians strive to deny the special Malay rights, it clearly means that they are striving to deny Your Majesty’s rights to become the ruler of this country and the right of upholding Islam as the official religion of the country.
It is DYMM Tuanku and all the Malay rulers who have entrusted the politicians the power to rule this country. The power to rule this country belongs to DYMM Tuanku and all the Malay rulers and not to the politicians. Power and honour only belong to Allah and there is no one who own power and honour except Allah. According to the orders of Allah and the Sunnah of His Prophet saw when there are three among you; one must be made an Amir. The Amir shall be entrusted with power and the power shall be used by the Amir to establish the orders of Allah. As long as that person is an Amir, all his orders that are not against the orders of Allah have to be listened to, obeyed and followed. Malaysia must have an Amir who is under the patronage of Allah SWT, and the rightful owner of the position of the Amir is the DYMM Tuanku. Having a bad Amir is better than not having an Amir at all. There should not be a situation in Malaysia whereby we do not have an Amir. When we do not have an Amir, we are not obeying the orders of Allah; and Allah will be displeased with us.
When DYMM Tuanku is our Amir, the power to established law and orders in Malaysia lies upon the DYMM Tuanku and all the rulers. When the Prime Minister has failed to execute his responsibilities, DYMM Tuanku and all the rulers must take over the power from the Prime Minister and choose another Prime Minister, so that law and orders will again be established in Malaysia. DYMM Tuanku doesn’t have to use the democracy system to choose the Prime Minister. In Islam, whenever there are no revelation or wahyu to solve our problems, Allah ordered us to solve our problems through the mesyuarah of syura council. DYMM Tuanku can use the mesyuarah of syura council to choose the Prime Minister. The members of the syurah councils shall comprise all the Malay rulers in particular and others whom DYMM Tuanku feels qualified to become the members of the council.
Since DYMM Tuanku rules as an Amir for only five years, the appointment of the Prime Minister may also be reviewed after every five years. DYMM Tuanku and all the rulers must put the responsibility to establish peace, law and order above the system. In a democratic system the majority rules; and if the majority of the people are evil doers, an evil person would most probably be elected to become the Prime Minister.
Currently we are practicing Constitutional Monarchy, following the system developed by our colonial master. Although Your Majesty is the ruler or the Amir of this country, but in constitutional monarchy, Your Majesty has neither the advisory nor the executive power. In constitutional Monarchy, Your Majesty’s role as an Amir is made dormant and inactive. Your Majesty is regarded as nothing more than just a symbol. Islam recognizes only two systems of governance. The first one is Caliphate and the second one is Monarchy. The history shows us that there are four companions of the Prophet saw who had became the Caliph and were known as The Guided Caliphs and one companion of the Prophet saw who was a King. Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali were the Guided Caliphs and Hazrat Muawiyah was the example of a King. When Muslims are good believers, the Caliphate or Monarchial system of governance are most suitable for their well beings.
Muslims in Malaysia will become real believers when all Muslims in Malaysia seriously do the work of inviting people to good and forbidding people from evils. If Malaysia wants to follow the Islamic system of governance, a Monarchy system of governance is currently the most suitable system. DYMM Tuanku is the King and the Amir of Malaysia and to help DYMM Tuanku manages the country, DYMM Tuanku with the consultation of the syurah council may appoints a Prime Minister. The Prime Minister, upon advice from DYMM Tuanku, will appoint his Cabinet Ministers whom will assist him in executing all the policies and the directions established by DYMM Tuanku.
Democracy is not an Islamic system and it has never been used by the Prophet saw, the Companions of the Prophet saw and the Muslims in the past. Democracy is a system of governance developed by the ancient Romans who were non-Muslims. In a democratic system, the majority rules and when the majority of the people are evil doers, evil will definitely rules the day. Hence, Allah never commanded to the Prophet saw to implement the democratic system simply because it is not the most suitable governing system to benefit mankind. It is a system developed by men and certainly it has many flaws and weaknesses.
As a Muslim, we have to obey the orders of Allah’s including to re-establish the governing system shown by Allah to the Prophet saw and his companions. Nowadays, there are many countries in the world that are not practicing a democratic system of governance yet they are accepted and respected by the world. China and Saudi Arabia for instance do not practice a democratic system, yet they were accepted and welcomed by the UN.
When the democratic system of governance is no longer capable of securing peace and harmony in Malaysia, DYMM Tuanku as the rightful Amir of Malaysia and all the Malay Rulers are in the position to opt for an Islamic System of governance that is the Monarchial system instead of maintaining the present democratic system of governance. Islamic system of governance is a system shown by Allah to the Prophet saw and has been practiced by the Companions of the Prophet saw and the Muslims after them.
Islamic system of governance does not require General Elections to be done. Without the General Elections, Malaysia will be able to save a lot of money which can be used to benefit the citizens. Malaysia will be saved from falling into the hands of the devils and the evil doers. When we use the Islamic system of governance, this country will be blessed by Allah with peace and prosperity. DYMM Tuanku and all the Malay Rulers will be regarded by Allah as obedient servants of Allah. DYMM Tuanku and all the Malay rulers will be remembered for generations to come as those who were responsible in reviving the Islamic system of governance in this world. When we obey Allah by following the way of Prophet Muhammad saw, we will be successful in the eyes of our Creator, Allah SWT. May Allah blesses and guides DYMM Tuanku and all the Malay Rulers to the path taken by His beloved Prophet Muhammad saw.
I have fulfilled my responsibility to remind Your Majesty DYMM Tuanku, all the Malay Rulers and all the Malay political leaders in this blessed country solely with the intention of obeying the orders of Allah and to please Allah until I become one of the lovers of Allah . To my utmost capability, I have tried to remind Your Majesty DYMM Tuanku, the Malay Rulers and the Malay political leaders in the most polite manner. Were I not polite enough to the standard of Your Majesty, may I ask forgiveness from Your Majesty and from Allah SWT.
Daulat Tuanku !
Ampun Tuanku. Apa yang patek persembahkan harap diampun. Patek mohon mengundur diri.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
January 2011
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

PAS is moving forward towards becoming a real political party. This recent Muktamar of PAS has shown the true colour of PAS ~laporan TV3. PAS is a political party and not an islamic and dakwah movement CLICK. PAS should behave like other political parties if PAS is to join in the rat race of gaining power and glamour. PAS must change in its approach if PAS is to win in the next election. It takes PAS such a long time to realise its true colours. It is true that many people are allergic with the slogan of negara Islam and it is not only the members of DAP who are allergic to the slogan but also many Muslims. PAS should have realised it a long time ago that the slogan of negara Islam is not compatible to Malaysian politic. PAS needs probably the advice of others to change the slogan from negara Islam to negara Berkebajikan. Why PAS takes so long to understand about politics? It is because PAS was controlled previously by groups of Ulama who are not trained to become politicians but train to become teachers or preachers. When Ulama who are trained as teachers start to become politicians, until now, PAS remain a spectator in the political arena of the country. More than 57 years PAS has become only the spectators and now PAS is moving towards becoming the main players in the political scenario of Malaysia. PAS members must realised that PAS is not a dakwah movement and same as Tabligh Jamat is only a tarikat groups CLICK. When PAS realised its real identity as a political party and not a dakwah movement, then PAS will be able to move forward to become a political party. In my opinion PAS should change even the meaning of the name PAS, from Parti Islam Semalaysia to Parti Berkebajikan Semalaysia. I think in this way PAS will be more competitive with other political parties in Malaysia. We cannot mix the arts of politic with the arts of teaching and preaching. Whenever we teach and preach, we must always teach and preach the truth and sometimes we are angry with the students, but when we are making a political speech, we must speak according to the tune of the audience and we must never get angry with our enemies. In a political speech, you may not have to lie but you may not tell the truth. In politic, you will only talks what you audiences like to hear you talking.
Many PAS politicians are religious teachers and they behave more like teachers rather than a politicians. Because of this, PAS is not appealing to the general public. When PAS politicians who are basically teachers and preachers, speaks in public, they generally speak like a teachers. A teacher is a person who thinks that the persons who are listening to him are their students and are inferior to them. When teachers speak, they speak in an instructive ways and they will speak the truth and in politic, you must speak what your audience wants you to speak. In politics peoples do not want to hear the truth because the truths are often painful. Even though you do not speak the plain truth in politic, but you should not make false promises in a political talk. The basis in any political talks is to speak what your audiences want you to speak. Many PAS politicians are not trained to give political talks and when they start to give false promises as for examples if you vote for PAS you will enter paradise, this talk is the talk of a bad teacher who turns politicians. PAS has to train their members of parliaments on how to give political speech and to make reasonable promises. Every promises made to the public must be fulfilled. Any politicians who make so many promises are usually made false promises. When PAS politicians speak they must, speak so that peoples are happy to hear their speeches. When PAS politicians act as a teacher, and treat the audience as their students they start to behave arrogantly towards them. When PAS politicians start to curse other peoples in their speeches, or gives warning that they will becomes infidels if they do not join PAS, many people will turn away from PAS. PAS politicians must wear dresses that the majority of the public wears. PAS politicians must behave like the normal ordinary peoples on the street and they must be humble and willing to help anybody irrespective of their race and religions. PAS politicians and PAS members should not put the wearing of Islamic attires as their priorities and PAS members should not wear clothes that make them look more Islamic than the other normal ordinary Muslim. In order to be more appealing to the general public, PAS members must wear as ordinary dresses as possible.
It is time for PAS to become a matured and professional political party. PAS should not has the slogan ‘Kepimpinan Ulama’. We are not to make peoples without any qualities of a leader to become our leaders. When we make those that do not have the qualities of leaders as our leaders, we are moving PAS towards disaster. PAS must change the slogan to ‘Kepimpinan berkualiti’ and PAS must have many leaders with qualities. It is not necessary that the President of PAS must be an Ulama but he must be a person with many good qualities that fit to become the Prime Minister of Malaysia. PAS has been influenced in the past by peoples with emotions but not with brains. Allah does not make women as leaders because they are influenced more by their emotion rather than by their brains. All these while PAS is more driven by emotion rather than by reality. The first four caliphs of Islam are not from those who are spending more times in teaching Islamic knowledge in Madrasah or Islamic Schools but they are the ordinary Muslims. We should not think only Ustaz can become the leaders of PAS but everyone with leadership qualities can become the leaders of PAS. PAS should not made their members into two camps, the camps of Professional and the camps of Ulama as this is damaging to a healthy growth of PAS. In Jamat Tabligh, they group peoples who are Ustaz as ‘orang agama’ and those who are not Ustaz as ‘orang dunia’. We should not be influenced by the narrow mindedness of certain quarters of Muslims, as all Muslims are the same and Muslims only differ in their taqwa. It is not true that all Ustaz are taqwa and those who are not Ustaz are not taqwa.
As a party that gives priorities to ‘Kebajikan’ all PAS members and PAS members of Parliament should give priorities to do “Kebajikan” to the peoples irrespective of race. PAS members must embark on helping to clean deserted mosques and surau, visiting and helping deserted families, visiting and helping old folk homes, visiting and helping the blinds and the deaf and the unfortunates and all those who are in needs of help. Can PAS do all this which I have suggested? If PAS is willing to do all the actions that reflect its true image of Parti Berkebajikan Semalaysia, in no time PAS will be the ruling Parti in Malaysia. PAS can be on its own if PAS is really a party that put Kebajikan above all. Not only the Malay but the Chinese and the Indian will vote for PAS, because PAS is true to its slogan. PAS has chosen the correct slogan and PAS must work hard to live to that slogan. I congratulate PAS for choosing the correct slogan. When PAS is acting to the slogan of Parti Berkebajikan, PAS can stand on its own. In order to be a favourite political party, PAS does not have to become the enemies of Umno or other parties. When PAS attack the Malay Party Umno, PAS is looking for a very great trouble from the Malays who love Umno. Umno has done many great things to the Malay and the country, including the effort of getting independence from the British. PAS has only started to Berkebajikan but Umno has started Berkebajikan a long times ago, except Umno can do even more. PAS should be friendly to all but politically PAS should remain alone as suggested by Tun Dr Mahathir. When PAS join DAP which are dislike by many Malays, PAS will lose influence on the Malays. PAS as a political party must do what all the Malays, Chinese and Indians likes. PAS can win the most votes in the next election if PAS is doing what all the races like. PAS must dissociate herself from the image of Anwar Ibrahim as Anwar is full with scandals. Whatever the PAS leaders do to denied the issues, it will not work. The video sex of Anwar is showing that, one of the actors is Anwar Ibrahim and the video sex has spread all over the country. PAS is a political parties and as a political parties PAS cannot be showing any sympathy and pity to those who can jeopardise her performance in the next election. PAS must take the brave action to leaves both PKR and DAP and concentrate on making PAS a party Berkebajikan to all. When we do ‘Kebajikan’, everyone will love us including our enemies. PAS can stand on its own when PAS is willing to do all the above suggestions of me. When PAS rub out the name Islam from the party it does not mean PAS is not Islamic. Allah does not look at the names but Allah looks at the actions. Generally many Malays, has becomes the slaves to their emotions and they prefer outward appearance more than the real actions. When PAS give preference to actions rather than outward appearance, PAS will become the most successful political party in Malaysia. Non-Muslims who like to do kebajikan can become the members of PAS but they cannot become the leaders of PAS unless they become Muslims.
PAS should drop the slogan of Negara Islam, Hudud Laws CLICK and Kepimpinan Ulama. All these slogans are hindrance towards making PAS a political party. PAS must clearly acts like a political party. PAS should not try to looks Islamic but do more Islamic works. All this while the focus of most members of PAS is on the outward appearance but now the focus should be on actions, which is kebajikan. In my opinion, if PAS is doing kebajikan to the peoples, then in the future PAS will emerge as the best political party in Malaysia.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
June 2011
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

What is the greatest evil against Allah? The greatest evil done by men against Allah is not to recognize that there is no God except Allah and not to recognize that Muhammad is the Prophet of Allah. What is the greatest evil done by those who have recited the Great Kalimah against Allah? The greatest evil done by those who have recited the Great Kalimah against Allah is not to do the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils. The second great evil done by those who have recited the Great Kalimah against Allah is not to perform the five times daily prayers. In my opinion when the first order of Allah is already established in the country then only the second order of Allah will have to be established in the country. What is the second order of Allah? The second order of Allah is to perform the five times daily prayers. Once the first and the second order of Allah are established in the country then only the next order of Allah will have to be established in the country. The next order of Allah to be established in a country that wanted to become an Islamic country is the order of zakat which is fardu or obligatory only to those who are rich and wealthy in the country. In my opinion, these are the three most important orders of Allah to be established in any country that wishes to become an Islamic country. Who has given Muhammad Mursi the power to rule Mesir? Allah has given Muhammad Mursi the power to rule Mesir. In my opinion the power which is given to Muhammad Mursi to rule Mesir should be used to establish the above first three orders of Allah which are mentioned above and not to change the constitutions of Mesir in order to ensure the President will have the position above the laws.
When Muhammad Mursi wanted to change the constitutions of Mesir, in order to enable him to have positioned above the laws, there were thousands of people protesting in Tahrir square demanding him to step down as the President of Mesir. In my opinion the action to change the constitutions of Mesir in order to enable the President to have positioned above the law is not a very wise action of the President. In my opinion, one of the earliest tasks to be accomplished by Muhammad Mursi as the President of Mesir was to unite the peoples of Mesir and to make the armies to obey him. In my opinion the process of making Mesir to become an Islamic state should take a long and slow process. We have to make the process to make Mesir an Islamic state a long and slow process so that in case we make mistakes along the process then it is easy for us to recover from the mistake. In case, we make the process of making Mesir an Islamic state, a fast and drastic pace then it will be difficult for us to go back to the correct path when in case we makes mistakes along the process. When we wanted a change anything in this world the change must take a very slow process because it is a rule in this world, everything in this world take time to change. All changes in this world are taking a slow pace. Only the changes in paradise will take a fast and drastic pace. What should be the first action of Muhammad Mursi as the first civilian President of Mesir? In my opinion the first action which Muhammad Mursi should do as the first civilian President of Mesir is establish the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils in every mosque or localities in Mesir. With the permission of Allah, the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils will prepare the mind and believe of the Muslims in every locality in Mesir to finally accept the idea that Mesir should become an Islamic state. Muslims in all over the world should not follow the style of the Taliban who wanted the Muslims in Afghanistan to change to become better Muslims by forcing the Muslims to follow the rules from the Quran. There is no one in this world who will obey the rules from the Quran without becoming the believers and there is no one who will become the believers after reciting the Great Kalimah without doing the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils in the way done by Prophet Muhammad saw.
Mohammad Mursi wanted to change the constitutions of Mesir to follow the Quran and Sunnah. In my opinion there is no need to change the constitutions of Mesir to follow the Quran and Sunnah when the Muslims in Mesir are not the believers. Many Muslims are able to read the Quran but since they are not believers they are not able to obey the Quran. In my opinion, there will be no one in Mesir who will obey the constitution of Mesir which is drafted according to the Quran and Sunnah if the Muslims in Mesir are not the believers. What is the first action which should be taken by a President who wanted his country to become an Islamic country? The first action which should be taken by a President who wanted his country to become an Islamic country is to make all the Muslims in his country to become the believers. Muslims will only become the believers when they do the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils in the way shown by Prophet Muhammad saw. What is the situation of the Muslims in this world today? When the name Islamic state is mentioned to the Muslims and the non-Muslims there are so many peoples from among the Muslims or the non-Muslims in this world who are allergic with the word Islamic state. Why there are so many peoples in this world who are allergic with the word Islamic state? They become allergic with the word Islamic state because there are Muslims like the Taliban who wanted to establish an Islamic state and yet they do not know the way to establish an Islamic state.
When the Taliban are not believers and yet they wanted to establish Afghanistan as an Islamic state, they make many mistakes or many wrong actions. The many wrong actions of the Taliban have made many peoples who are either Muslims or non-Muslims in this world to become allergic with the word of Islamic state. When Muhammad Mursi wanted to change the constitution of Mesir to follow the Quran and the Sunnah, it had given a clear indication to the Muslims in Mesir and to the peoples of the whole world that Muhammad Mursi is about to make Mesir an Islamic state. The actions of Muhammad Mursi to change the constitution of Mesir to follow the Quran and Sunnah have created much anxiety not only among the Muslims in Mesir but also among those followers of Hosni Mubarak, the armies and all the Muslims who are not in favour of making Mesir an Islamic state. When this situation of much anxiety among the peoples arises in Mesir then the Muslims who are not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir are using the anxieties of the peoples as the weapon to overthrow Mohammad Mursi. The action of Mohammad Mursi to recite the azan, while giving lecture also give the impression to the peoples of Mesir that Mohammad Mursi is an extremist who is probably similar to the Taliban. In the PASt there were many Muslims leaders in this world who wanted to establish Islamic laws in their countries. In the PASt there were many Muslims leaders who had failed to make their countries to become an Islamic state. They had failed to make their countries an Islamic state because they do not have the knowledge on how to make their countries an Islamic state. They do not have the knowledge which order of Allah is to be established first before the country is able to become an Islamic country. Taliban had failed in making Afghanistan an Islamic state. Similarly Pakistani Muslims had failed in making Pakistan an Islamic state. Now the Muslims Brotherhood of Mesir had also failed in making Mesir an Islamic state.
Pakistan was created in 1947 because the Muslims of India wanted to establish a separate Islamic state. What happen to Pakistan now? Is Pakistan is an Islamic state? Although Pakistan is known to the Muslims in the whole world to be a country which is strong in the work of Jemaah Tabligh but to the peoples of the whole world, Pakistan is known to be the most unsafe or dangerous country to live in this world. Pakistan and Afghanistan are rated by the United Nations to be the countries which produce terrorism or the countries which are the most volatile places to live on earth. Is this an Islamic country or a terrorist country? What was the original aim of creating Pakistan? The original aim of creating Pakistan was to establish an Islamic state of Pakistan. Pakistan was initially created as west and east Pakistan and both parts of Pakistan are inhabited by Muslims. In 1971 Muslims from the west and Muslims from the east were killing each other in a war, which has led to the creation of another state of the Muslims in India which is known as Bangladesh. In my opinion the situation in Pakistan in 1971 is probably the same as the situation in Mesir in 2013. In both situations the Muslims are killing other Muslims. Why the Muslims in Mesir are killing each other? They are killing each other because both groups of the Muslims wanted to have the power to rule Mesir. Why Muslims Brotherhood wanted to have power to rule Mesir? Muslims Brotherhood wanted to have power to rule Mesir because they said they wanted to establish the Islamic laws in Mesir. Why the other group wanted to have power to rule Mesir? They said they wanted to have power to rule Mesir because they wanted to maintain Mesir a secular state.
Is to establish Islamic laws in a country, the order of Allah? In my opinion, Allah only orders the Muslims whom Allah has given the power to rule a country, to establish Islamic laws in the country. Allah does not order the Muslims whom Allah has not given the power to rule a country to establish Islamic laws in the country. Allah orders Muslims to work to earn a living but Allah does not order Muslims to work to earn power and wealth. Allah gives power and wealth to whoever Allah wants. Allah gives power and wealth to a believer in order to examine the iman of the believer. Allah continues to examine the iman of the believer until the believers had PASsed the entire test or the examination which are given by Allah to the believers. With the entire entire test or the examination which are given by Allah to the believers the iman of the believer become further increased. Allah orders the Muslims to earn iman and good actions or to earn the nearness to Allah. Allah also orders Muslims to earn their needs but Allah does not order Muslims to earn wealth and power. Allah gives wealth and power to the persons who are not the believers as calamities but Allah gives wealth and power to the believers as trials or examinations.The persons who are not the believers will use the wealth and power which are given by Allah as the means to disobey the orders of Allah. When they use the power and the wealth which are given by Allah to disobey the orders of Allah, Allah will send calamities to them in this world and in the hereafter. The persons who are the believers will use the wealth and power which are given by Allah to them as the means to obey the orders of Allah. When the believers use the power and the wealth which are given by Allah to them for obeying the orders of Allah, Allah will send blessings to them in this world and in the hereafter. It is not the order of Allah to work in order to earn power and wealth. Allah orders Muslims to work in order to earn a living. Allah does not order Muslims to work hard in order to earn wealth and power but Allah orders the Muslims to work hard in order to earn iman and good actions. Allah promises to the Muslim, that He will give to the Muslims the power and wealth, when the Muslims have obtained good iman and good actions. Allah does not order the Muslims to earn wealth and power? Allah does not order the Muslims to earn power in order to establish the Islamic laws in a country? The order to establish the Islamic laws in a country are given only to those whom Allah has given the power, to rule the country
When Muslims are not given by Allah the power to rule a country, then there is no order for the Muslims to earn power in order to establish Islamic laws in the country. Allah does not order the Muslims in Mesir to earn power in order to establish Islamic laws in Mesir. Allah orders all the Muslims not only in Mesir but Muslims in all over the world to invite mankind to good and prevent mankind from evils as done by Prophet Muhammad saw. When Muslims do the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils as done by Prophet Muhammad saw and also with the intention only to please Allah then Allah will make the Muslims to become believers and have good actions. When Muslims have become believers and have good actions then Allah will give to the believers the power to rule not only Mesir but the power to rule the whole world. Allah does not order the Muslims to earn power and wealth but Allah orders the Muslims to earn the love of Allah or to earn good iman and good actions. Muslims will only earn the love of Allah when the Muslims have good iman and good actions. Muslims will only have good iman and good actions when Muslims are doing the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils as done by Prophet Muhammad saw. In my opinion, it is not justified for Muslims to be killed only because they wanted to gain power in order to establish the Islamic laws in a country. It is even not justified for Muslims to be killed when the order to gain power in order to establish the Islamic laws in a country is not the order of Allah?
Allah never orders Muslims to gain power in order to establish the Islamic laws in a country as power only belongs to Allah. Allah has promised to the Muslims that Allah will give power to the Muslims and Allah will make the Muslims who have good iman and good actions to become the Khilafah on this earth. Allah orders Muslims to earn the love of Allah not to earn wealth and power. When Muslims have earned the love of Allah, Allah will give to the Muslims the power to rule the earth. In my opinion, Muslims should only die in the cause of obeying the order of Allah or in the cause of earning the love of Allah. In my opinion the Muslims should die only in the cause of doing the work of inviting mankind to good and preventing mankind from evils in the way done by Prophet Muhammad saw and not to die in the work to earn power and wealth. When Muslims are inviting the non-Muslims to recite the Great Kalimah it means the Muslims are doing the work of inviting mankind to good and preventing mankind from evils. When Muslims are inviting other Muslims to obey the orders of Allah particularly the first and the second order of Allah, it means the Muslims are doing the work of inviting mankind to good and preventing mankind from evils.
Muslims are ordered to bear patiently to those who are doing evils to them. What it means by the word to bear patiently? The word, to bear patiently in the verse of the Quran means, to return evil actions with good actions. What is the best action? The best action means to invite the non-Muslims to recite the Great Kalimah. What is the best action of those who have recited the Great Kalimah? The best action of those who have recited the Great Kalimah is to do the work of inviting men to good and preventing men from evils. When Muslims have the intention to kill each other, either they are killed or they are being killed by the other Muslims, both of them will enter the hellfire. One time in a battle with the non-Muslims there was one companion of the Prophet saw who had killed one non-Muslim who at the time when the companion was about to kill him, had recited the Great Kalimah. Prophet Muhammad saw asked the companion the reason why he had killed a person, who had recited the Great Kalimah. The companion told Prophet Muhammad saw that he had killed the person who had recited the Great Kalimah because that person was not sincere in reciting the Great Kalimah and that he had recited the Great Kalimah because he feared death. Our Prophet Muhammad saw told the companion who had killed the person who had recited the Great Kalimah whether the companion knows what is inside the person’s heart. This story clearly shows to all the Muslims in this world that Allah and Prophet Muhammad saw has forbidden Muslims to kill those who have recited the Great Kalimah or in other word, Allah and Prophet Muhammad saw has forbidden Muslims to kill other Muslims.
Muslims are not allowed to kill anyone who has recited the Great Kalimah even the one who has recited the Great Kalimah is a hypocrite or a munafiqin. There is no one who knows that a person is a munafiqin or hypocrite except Allah. Our Prophet Muhammad saw knows who the munafiqin are because Allah had told him who the munafiqin are. What is happening to Mesir now is a great shame to all the Muslims in the whole world. Now, in Mesir the Muslims are killing other Muslims. What has happened to Mesir also happen in Pakistan, Afghanistan and many other Muslims countries in this world? It seems to me, that the Muslims in the whole world are not having the leaders to lead them or not having the Muslims scholars who are able to solve their problems. What has happened to the Muslims now? It is a shame that the person who becomes the mediator to solve the problems of the Muslims is not the ulama of the Muslims or the Muslims leaders but the President of USA and the leaders of the European Unions. What Muslims are good at? It seems the Muslims in this world are good only in creating problems but are not good at solving their own problems. In my opinion what has happened to the Muslims now in this world only to show to me and to all the other Muslims in this world that now the Muslims are not the best nation which Allah has promised to the Muslims in the Quran? Why the promise of Allah to make the Muslims to become the best nation is not fulfilled by Allah?
Allah promised that Muslims will become the best nation in this world, when Muslims have become the believers and have good actions. When Muslims are not doing the work of inviting mankind to good and preventing mankind from the evils in the way shown by the Prophet Muhammad saw and with intention to please only Allah, Allah will not make Muslims to become believers. When Muslims are not believers, the promise of Allah to make the Muslims the best nation in this world will not be fulfilled by Allah. The promise to make Muslims the best nation is meant only for the Muslims who have become the believers. Muslims will become believers only when Muslims are doing the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils. When Muslims are not doing the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils not only the Muslims do not become the believers but Allah will not grant the prayers of the Muslims, Allah will not grant the wishes of the Muslims and Allah will not assist the Muslims against their enemies.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
December 2013
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

All the reasons given by the armies to overthrow the President are not valid and not according to the Quran and Sunnah. Hazrat Othman was killed because he refused to step down as the President of the Muslims. He refused to step down as the President of the Muslims because he obeys the order of Prophet Muhammad saw. What was the order of Prophet Muhammad saw to Hazrat Othman? Prophet Muhammad saw ordered him not to step down in case he was forced to step down as the President of the Muslims. Hazrat Othman chooses to be killed by the demonstrators rather than to disobey the order of Allah and Prophet Muhammad saw. When a Muslim has been chosen by the Muslims to become the President of the Muslims, there is no one or any group among the Muslims who can order the person to step down as the President of the Muslims. The President of the Muslims should step down from becoming the President of the Muslims when there are many among the good Muslims of the country who also wanted him to step down as the President of the Muslims. It is wrong for the armies to overthrow the President who has been chosen by the Muslims in Mesir. The action of the armies to overthrow President Muhammad Mursi is forbidden in Islam. What should the armies of Mesir do? The armies of Mesir should listen only to the orders of the President Mohammad Mursi. The armies of Mesir should take instructions only from the President of Mesir and not from USA or Israel. In case the armies are receiving instructions from the USA or Israel to overthrow President Muhammad Mursi, it means the armies of Mesir are committing a very treacherous act against the peoples of Mesir.
What should be the punishment for those who are committing treacherous actions against the peoples of Mesir? In this case, what should the peoples of Mesir do? The peoples of Mesir should charge the army chiefs for treacherous actions against the peoples of Mesir. In case found guilty the army chiefs should be hanged to death. Now the armies of Mesir are killing the demonstrators who are Muslims, and the action of killing the demonstrators who are the Muslims will not solve the problems in Mesir but it will only accentuate the problems of Mesir. What is the order of Allah when two Muslims are in disagreement about something? The order of Allah when two Muslims are in disagreement about something is to bring the two Muslims who are in disagreement to the negotiation table and their disagreement must be solved by using the Quran and the Sunnah. On the other hand the armies are trying to solve the problem of Mesir by killing the Muslims who had refused to listen to their orders? Are the armies not the Muslims, who read the Quran and who understand the language of the Quran? Do the armies know about how to solve the problems of Mesir according to Quran and Sunnah? Their problems should be solved by bringing both of the groups who are in disagreement with each other on the negotiation table. In my opinion one renown Muslim scholar of Mesir should be invited to become the chairman of the meeting so that the disagreements between the two groups can be resolved by using the Quran and Sunnah. Is it not Mesir the land of Muslims scholars and the land which produces many Muslims scholars?
In my opinion, when there is a crisis between Muslims, it should not be the armies who should become the mediator between the Muslims who have the clashes but the Muslims scholars. Where are the Muslims scholars of Mesir? Are there Muslims scholars in Mesir? Or there is none who is the true Muslims scholars in Mesir. In my opinion, Mesir and all other Muslims countries only have the Muslims scholars who know about how to read the Quran and the Muslims scholars who know about how to read the Islamic books but not the Muslims scholars who are the believers. Only the Muslims scholars who are believers are given by Allah the understanding of the Quran and Sunnah. When Mesir and all the other Muslims countries only have the Muslims scholars who are not the believers then the Muslims scholars are not given by Allah the understanding of the Quran and Sunnah. When there are no Muslims scholars who are the believers and who understand about Quran and Sunnah then there is none from among the Muslims scholars in Mesir and other Muslims countries who are able to solve the current crisis in Mesir. What a shame to the entire Muslims in the whole world when the entire Muslims in the whole world are not able to solve the problems of the Muslims in Mesir. I am convinced that the problems in Mesir can be solved by the Muslims in case there is among the Muslims scholars in the whole world there are some who are the believers. When a decision according to the Quran and Sunnah is reached I am convinced that both parties will come to an agreement and the problem in Mesir will be solved.
We have PAS in Malaysia which is very similar to the Muslims Brotherhood of Mesir. The ulama of PAS also gives the fatwa that the members of PAS who have died in the clashes with the Malaysian Police force at Mamali, Baling Kedah in 1985 were also syuhadah. Are they really syuhadah? In my opinion, they are not syuhadah because they died while having clashes with the members of the Malaysian Police Force who were the majority are also Muslims. The policemen who had killed the Muslims in Mamali will enter the hellfire and the members of the PAS who were killed by the policemen but who also had the intention to kill the policemen who were also Muslims will also enter hellfire. In my opinion, the members of PAS who had died in Mamali were not syuhadah but the dwellers of the hellfire. The war between the Taliban and the Pakistani armies are also the war between Muslims. The Taliban are Muslims and they are killing the Pakistani armies who are also Muslims. When Muslims have the intention to kill each other then both the Muslims either the ones who were killed or the Muslims who were being killed are the dwellers of hellfire. Whoever recites the Great Kalimah is a Muslim. There is no one who could deny the fact that the persons who are reciting the Great Kalimah are Muslims. There is no one who could deny the fact that the persons who are reciting the Great Kalimah are Muslims because there is no one except Allah who knows what is inside the person’s heart. It is a great sin to kill a person who has recited the Great Kalimah and the believers. Muslims are not allowed to kill another Muslim and the believers.
Allah will declare war against those who killed the believers. Muslims are allowed have war only with the non-Muslims and the war started by non-Muslims who are angry with the Muslims because the Muslims are inviting them to become Muslims. Muslims are not allowed to have war with other Muslims even to those Muslims who wanted to have war with them. Muslims are not allowed have war with the non-Muslims who wanted to have peace with the Muslims. In Islam, war should be avoided as much as possible and war should not be the first choice of action to be used in order to solve the problems of the Muslims. In my opinion, war should not be used at all in solving any problems among the Muslims. Our Prophet Muhammad saw had tried his level best to avoid war with the Meccan peoples when he entered Mecca with armies of more than one hundred thousand people. In my opinion the Malaysian government should not have used the war in solving the problems of Mamali. The armies of Mesir should not have used the war in solving the problems of Mesir. Palestine and Israel should not have used war in solving the problems of Palestine and Israel. War is not the action which follows the Sunnah of our Prophet Muhammad saw. Prophet Muhammad saw was not using war in order to solve the problems of Muslims and the whole mankind. War was not the first choice of action which was used by our Prophet Muhammad saw in solving the problems of the Muslims or the problems between Muslims or the problems between Muslims and the non-Muslims. Using war in order to solve the problems of the Muslims is not following the teaching of the Quran and Sunnah. Similarly the problem in Mesir will not be solved by the armies declaring war with the demonstrators who refused to recognize the interim government.
When Muslims have disagreement between them, Allah orders the Muslims to solve their disagreement by using the Quran and Sunnah. What is the way of the Quran and the Sunnah? The way of the Quran and Sunnah is the way of our Prophet Muhammad saw. There are so many ulama or Muslims scholars in Mesir who are supposed to be well versed with the Quran and the Sunnah. The University of Al-Azhar which is located in Mesir had produced million of ulama in this world. Are there not many Muslims and Muslims scholars in Mesir who are able to memorize the Quran and to understand the meaning of the Quran? Are there not many Muslims and Muslims scholars in Mesir who are able to read the Quran in such melodies voices? There are so many Muslims in Mesir and there are so many Muslims scholars in Mesir. Is there anyone among the many millions of Muslims and thousands of Muslims scholars in Mesir who knows how to solve the problems in Mesir? Since there are problems in Mesir and until now the problems are not solved, therefore I conclude that there is none among the millions of Muslims and thousands of Muslims scholars in Mesir who is able to use the Quran and Sunnah in solving the problems of Mesir which also means that there is none in Mesir who is the believer who really understand about the Quran and the Sunnah and able to use the Quran and the Sunnah to solve the problem in Mesir. The peoples of Mesir have elected a President who is able to memorize the Quran but is not able to understand the Quran and to use the Quran in solving the problems in Mesir? In case Muhammad Mursi understands the Quran and the Sunnah then he should be able to use the Quran and Sunnah in solving the problems in Mesir and Mesir will have no problems.
In my opinion there is no one in Mesir who really understand the Quran and who is able to apply the Quran in solving the problems of Mesir. In case there is even only one person in Mesir who is able to understand the Quran and who is able to use the Quran in solving the problems in Mesir, certainly there will be no problems in Mesir. In order to make Mesir an Islamic state what should be the first order of Allah to be established in Mesir? Do Mohammad Mouse or any of the Muslims scholars in Mesir know, what should be the first order of Allah to be established in Mesir in order to make Mesir an Islamic state? Many of the Muslims scholars and Muslims believe that the first order of Allah to be established in a country which wanted to become an Islamic country is the Hudud law. Many believe that the Hudud Law is the mean to prevent the evil actions. What is the truth? The truth is Hudud Law is not the mean to prevent the evil actions. Allah orders the Muslims to prevent the evil actions not with Hudud law but with good actions. Hudud law will not prevent the evil actions as evil actions are prevented with good actions. Muslims will commit evil actions when they have weak iman. Muslims will not commit evil actions when they have strong iman or they have become the believers. Muslims will only have strong iman or will only become believers when they do the work of inviting men to do good and prevent men from evils in the way done by Prophet Muhammad saw. However there are many Muslims in Muslims Brotherhood and in PAS who believes that the first order of Allah to be established in a country that wanted to become an Islamic state is the Hudud law.
They also believe that Hudud law must be enforced only to the Muslims and not to the non-Muslims and because of that there are many Muslims in Mesir and in Malaysia who are not ready to welcome the implementation of Hudud law in Mesir and in Malaysia. What is the truth? In my opinion the truth is both the Muslims and the non-Muslims should be given the choice to choose either to be punished under the Civil law or under the Hudud law. In Islam there is no compulsion in religion. In my opinion the Muslims will choose to be punished under the Hudud law only when they are the believers. When Muslims are not the believers then they are not ready to be punished under the Hudud law. Many Muslims in Mesir and in Malaysia are not in favour of Hudud law because they are not believers. When Muslims are not believers they will prefer Mesir or Malaysia to remain a secular state and not an Islamic state. Muslims are able to obey the orders of Allah only when they have the foundation of Islam. What is the foundation of Islam? What surprise me; there are so many Muslims in this world who do not know what the foundation of Islam is? When they do not know what the foundation of Islam is, it means they do not have even the foundation of Islam in their lives. When they do not have the foundation of Islam in their lives, it means they do not have Islam in their lives. Many Muslims understand that the foundation in Islam is to have the knowledge about fardu ain in Islam.
Some Muslims also understand that to have the foundation of Islam is to have the knowledge about the Quran and Hadis. What is the truth about the foundation of Islam? The foundation of Islam is to have the Great Kalimah implanted in the mind and the soul of the Muslims. The Great Kalimah is implanted into the mind and the soul of the Muslims only when the Muslims are doing the work of inviting men to good and forbidding men from the evils in the way shown by the Prophet Muhammad saw. What should be the first order of Allah to be established in a country that wanted to become an Islamic country? The first order of Allah to be established in a country that wanted to become an Islamic country should be the order to invite mankind to good and to forbid mankind from evils and not the Hudud law. The order to invite mankind to good and to forbid mankind from evils is the order which fulfils the right of reciting the Great Kalimah. A Muslim who does not do the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils is not fulfilling the right of reciting the Great Kalimah. When a Muslim is not fulfilling the right of reciting the Great Kalimah it means the Muslim is not practicing the first pillar of the five pillars of Islam or the first Rukun of the five Rukun Islam. Prophet Muhammad saw was reported to have said to the companions with an approximate meaning; All persons who have recited the Great Kalimah will obtain the benefits of reciting the Great Kalimah unless that person is not fulfilling the right of reciting the Great Kalimah. The companions asked Prophet Muhammad saw; what is the right of reciting the Great Kalimah? Prophet Muhammad saw answered; when evils are openly done against Allah, the persons who are reciting the Great Kalimah are not preventing the persons from committing the evils against Allah. What is the evil action done openly against Allah? The evil action done openly against Allah is men openly not willing to accept or to recite I bear witness there is no God except Allah and I bear witness Muhammad is the messenger of Allah.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
December 2013
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

All the previous Presidents of Mesir were ex-army’s personals and were strongly supported by the armed forces of Mesir. For more than 50 years, the armed forces of Mesir have enjoyed the position which is similar to the position of a King in a monarchy system. I think the shrewd Politicians who are supported by 48% of the peoples and who are not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir were using the armed forces to overthrow Muhammad Mursi. In my opinion the action to overthrow Muhammad Mursi was wrong and the wrong actions were the means upon which Allah has sent calamities to the nation of Mesir. In order to remove the calamities which had been sent by Allah to the peoples of Mesir, the persons who did the wrong actions must make repentance or tube to Allah and they must replace the wrong actions with correct action. What is the correct action which they must do in order to make Mesir to return back to peace? They must install Muhammad Mursi back to become the President of Mesir. Allah forbids Muslims to kill other Muslims. All the persons who are in the army or with the Muslims Brotherhood are Muslims because all of them have recited the Great Kalimah. Muslims who have overthrown the President Muhammad Mursi and who have killed other Muslims are the Muslims have disobeyed the orders of Allah.
In my opinion, the Muslims in Mesir who are not with the Muslims Brotherhood are generally the Muslims who love the lifestyles of the non-Muslims rather than the lifestyle of the Muslims and they are generally the Muslims who love Mesir to become a secular nation rather than an Islamic nation. The Muslims who love the lifestyles of the non-Muslims rather than the lifestyle of the Muslims are not Kafir but they are Muslims who have very weak iman. Because they are the Muslims with weak iman they are unable to obey the orders of Allah. However the Muslims who are with Muslims Brotherhood are probably the Muslims who have slightly more iman than the Muslims who love the lifestyles of the non-Muslims but in my opinion they are not the believers. Generally the Muslims who are with Muslims Brotherhood want Mesir to become an Islamic state, who perform the five times prayers, who fast in the month of Ramadan, who pay zakat and who perform pilgrimage to Mecca but are not performing the first order of Allah. What is the first order of Allah? The first order of Allah is not only to recite the Great Kalimah but to fulfil the right of reciting the Great Kalimah. What is the right of reciting the Great Kalimah? The right of reciting the Great Kalimah is to do the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils.
When the Muslims are not doing the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils they will remain Muslims but with weak iman but they will not become the believers. When they are not believers, Allah will not give them the understanding of the Quran. The Muslims who do not have the understanding the Quran will interpret the Quran wrongly. As for examples the members of PAS or Muslims Brotherhood regards themselves as the true Muslims and the Muslims who are not with PAS or with Muslims Brotherhood are not the true Muslims while the leaders of PAS regard the members of UMNO as Kafir or non-Muslims. PAS leaders regard the Muslims who are with UMNO as Kafir. PAS members are usually the Muslims who perform the five times daily payers, who fast in the month of Ramadan, who pay zakat and who perform pilgrimage to Mecca but they are not doing the work which fulfil the right of reciting the Great Kalimah. When a Muslim is only reciting the Great Kalimah without doing the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils the way done by Prophet Muhammad saw it means the Muslim is not doing the work which fulfils the right of the Great Kalimah. When Muslims only recite the Great Kalimah without doing the work of inviting mankind to good and forbidding mankind from evils, their iman become very weak and when their iman are weak, they are not able to become the believers. When they are not the believers, they are not given by Allah the understanding of the Quran. When they are not given by Allah the understanding of the Quran, they will not know about how to implement the orders of Allah which are mentioned in the Quran.
Although Muhammad Mursi is the hafiz of Quran but I think he is not a believer. Because he is not a believer, he was not able to execute the various orders of Allah which are mentioned in the Quran in the way which was done by Prophet Muhammad saw. Generally the Muslims who are not with Muslims Brotherhood love the lifestyle of the non-Muslims, not in favour of Mohammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir and not in favour of Mesir to become an Islamic country. In my opinion, the ulama of Muslims Brotherhood are also not the persons who understand the Quran when they make the fatwa that; Muslims who are not in favour of Mesir to become an Islamic state are Kafir or secular Muslims. In my opinion the Muslims who are not in favour of Mesir to become an Islamic state are not Kafir or secular Muslims but Muslims who have disobeyed the orders of Allah. When the alarm of the Muslims Brotherhood had given the fatwa that the Muslims who are not in favour of Mesir to become an Islamic state are Kafir or secular Muslims then the Muslims who are with Muslims Brotherhood will regard the clashes between the members of Muslims Brotherhood and the armies is similar to the clashes between Muslims and non-Muslims. Because of the fatwa, the members of the Muslims Brotherhood have regard to die in the clashes with the armies is to die as the martyrs.
Muslims Brotherhood buried the Muslims whom they have regarded as martyrs similar to those Muslims who are the real martyrs. In my opinion the fatwa which is given by the ulama of Muslims Brotherhood is a wrong fatwa. In my opinion the wrong fatwa had caused the clashes between the Muslims Brotherhood and the armies to accelerate to a greater dimension which finally have led to many more casualties on the side of the armies as well as on the side of the Muslims Brotherhood. What is the correct fatwa? The correct Fatwa is that the clashes between the armies and Muslims Brotherhood are not Jihad but the clashes between two brothers in Islam. In the clashes between two brothers in Islam it is Haram for a Muslim to kill another Muslim and both the Muslims who are trying to kill each other; whether the Muslims who killed other Muslims or Muslims who have the intention to kill other Muslims but are being killed by other Muslims will enter the hellfire. Why the ulama of Muslims Brotherhood have given the fatwa that the clashes between the members of Muslims Brotherhood and the armies are similar to the clashes between Muslims and non-Muslims? They give this fatwa because they are arrogant and ignorant. Why I think they are arrogant and ignorant? I think they are arrogant and ignorant because they regard only the Muslims who are with Muslims Brotherhood are Muslims while the Muslims who are with the armies are Kafir. All the members of armies of Mesir are also Muslims because they too have recited the Great Kalimah. In Islam, it is not permissible to regard the persons who have recited the Great Kalimah as kafir and it is also not permissible to kill the persons who have recited the Great Kalimah. PAS also regard the Muslims in UMNO as Kafir when all the members of UMNO are reciting the Great Kalimah. I think, the ulama of PAS will also issue the same fatwa as the ulama of Muslims Brotherhood in case there are clashes between the members of UMNO and PAS. The clashes between Muslims and Muslims are not Jihad and to die in such clashes will not make the persons to become martyrs. Whoever kills his brothers in Islam will enter the hellfire. Irrespective whether the Muslims belong to Muslims Brotherhood or to the armies, but the person who had killed a Muslim will enter the hellfire.
The person who had killed even only one Muslim will enter the hellfire. Allah has forbidden Muslim to kill those who have recited the Great Kalimah. When two Muslims are trying to kill each other, both of them will enter hellfire irrespective whether in the clashes one Muslim is killed and the other Muslim remains alive. Allah values the person who has recited the Great Kalimah. Allah gives even more values to those Muslims who have become the believers. Allah forbids the Muslims from killing the persons who have recited the Great Kalimah and from killing the Muslims who are the believers. The armies should not kill the Muslims who were demonstrating and the Muslims who were demonstrating should not kill the armies. The armies who killed the Muslims who were demonstrating will certainly enter the hellfire. In my opinion the armies had the intention to kill the demonstrators who are mainly Muslims when the armies were using live ammunitions in trying to disperse the demonstrators. When the armies were killing the Muslims, it means the armies are the inhabitants of the hellfire. There is no justification for the armies to kill the demonstrators who are Muslims. All the demonstrators were without weapons and the armies should not regard them as the enemies of Mesir. In my opinion the clashes between the Muslims Brotherhood and the armies are the clashes between two brothers in Islam and it is not Jihad and whoever have died in the clashes will not make the persons to become the martyrs.
What is Jihad? Jihad is the war between Muslims and the non-Muslims. The war is not started by the Muslims but is started by the non-Muslims. The non-Muslims started to have a war with the Muslims because they dislike the Muslims to invite them to recite the Great Kalimah. The clashes which are happening in Mesir are the clashes between two brothers in Islam who have differences in opinions regarding the ways on how to govern Mesir. One group of the Muslims in Mesir wanted Mesir to become a secular state with laws which inherit from the colonial master while the other group of the Muslims in Mesir wanted Mesir to become an Islamic state with the laws of the Quran. In my opinion the armed forces of Mesir should not solve the political problem of Mesir by disposing President Mohammad Mursi but by negotiation. Why should the political clashes in Mesir be solved by negotiations and not by war? It should be solved by negotiations and not by war because the clashes arise between two brothers in Islam. In my opinion, the armed forces should not have interfered with the crisis but instead the armed forces should have chosen a qualified person who is respected by both parties to become the chairman in the negotiation. In my opinions the negotiations may take months or years but it should continue until both parties are satisfied with the outcomes of the negotiations. Negotiations should be the way on how the Muslims should resolve differences between them. Muslims who are not satisfied with the President should not have used the army to overthrow the President but they should have negotiations with the President. The action to overthrow the President by using the army is against the order of Allah.
The reason to overthrow the President because the President was only following the desires of Muslims Brotherhood or the President was not fulfilling his election promises are not the valid reasons to overthrow the President. The action to overthrow the President on whatever reasons is against the order of Allah. Allah forbids Muslims to overthrow their leaders who are performing prayers with them. The action to overthrow the President is a great sin. The peoples of Mesir should know that there is no President in the whole world who can fulfil the wishes of all of his people. Mohammad Mursi certainly is not able to fulfil the wishes of all the peoples of Mesir. When a President is not able to fulfil the wishes of some of his or her peoples, it does means the peoples whose wishes are not fulfilled by the President are allowed to use the army to overthrow the President. If this is the case, the country will continue to be in a state of chaos and turmoil as long as there are groups who are not satisfied with the Presidents of the country. The action to overthrow President Muhammad Mursi has set the precedent that whoever in Mesir who are not satisfied with the President are allowed to use the army to overthrow the President. What a shame to those in Mesir who claim to be the intellectuals and yet they are not able to solve the political problems of Mesir. The political turmoil in Mesir is created by the peoples of Mesir. By their own actions, they have created the political turmoil. Instead of using the army to overthrow the President, the peoples of Mesir should have exercised patience and forbearance. Who will solve the problems in Mesir?
There is no one who is able to solve the problems in Mesir except Allah. Allah will solve the problems of Mesir when the peoples of Mesir have good actions. Allah will not solve the problem of Mesir when the peoples of Mesir have wrong actions. The action to overthrow the President Muhammad Mursi was a wrong action. Why the peoples of Mesir have wrong actions? The peoples of Mesir have wrong actions because they have the wrong belief. What is their wrong belief? They believe that a new President will solve the problems in Mesir. Without the permission of Allah even a new President of Mesir will not be able to solve the problems in Mesir. Allah will solve the problems in Mesir only when the peoples of Mesir have good actions. The armies and the peoples who are not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir believe that to have a new President will solve the problems of Mesir. What has happened to Mesir now? The overthrow of President Muhammad Mursi is not solving the problems in Mesir but instead it has increased the problems in Mesir. When they overthrow the President who is performing prayers with them they have disobeyed the order of Allah. When they disobeyed the order of Allah, the wrath of Allah is descending upon them. When the wrath of Allah is descending upon the peoples of Mesir, Allah makes the peoples of Mesir to live in constant fear and anxiety. What is the rule of Allah? When men are doing good actions, Allah will send a blessing to them and when men are doing wrong actions, Allah will send calamities to them.
In my opinion the decision which was made by the armies to overthrow Mohammad Mursi is an immature decision. The immature decision of the armies is not solving the problems of Mesir but instead it has accentuated the problems. The immature decision has created chaos and turmoil in Mesir and the whole world. When a wrong decision is made it creates problems. When more wrong decisions are made it creates even more problems. In order to solve a problem, the method which is used to solve the problem must be correct. When the method to solve the problem is wrong then more problems will arise. The wrong method of solving the original problems of Mesir has created more problems to Mesir. What was the original problem of Mesir which the armies wanted to solve? The original problem is the President Muhammad Mursi. They were not satisfied with Muhammad Mursi as the President of Mesir and they wanted to remove the President. When they used the wrong method to remove the President they have created more problems to Mesir. Now the armies of Mesir who are Muslims are killing the Muslims of Muslims Brotherhood. One of the main reasons they wanted to overthrow President was because the President was giving more favours to the members of Muslims Brotherhood and not to the others.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
December 2013
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre

The first democratic general election to elect a President in Mesir was held in 2012 and Mohammad Mursi who was formerly the President of Muslims Brotherhood had won the general election and he was sworn as the first democratic President of Mesir. At the time when Mohammad Mursi was sworn as the President of Mesir, there were many who think dictatorship had ended and democracy has begun in Mesir. In the PASt, there were no democracy in Mesir and the first political party ever establishes in Mesir is probably Muslims Brotherhood. Muslims Brotherhood was established in the year 1920. It was only in 2012; Muslim Brotherhood was able to win the Presidential election of Mesir. It was 100 years later when the Muslims Brotherhood was able making its presence in Mesir being felt by the peoples of Mesir. At the time when Mohammad Mursi was sworn as the President of Mesir, the followers of Muslims Brotherhood in Mesir were in joy. They were in joy because they believe with Muhammad Mursi become the President of Mesir, their task to establish Mesir as an Islamic state will become an easy task. What was expected by the Muslims Brotherhood to be an easy task, it turns out to be a very difficult task? Although there are some Muslims in Mesir who are in favour to live in Mesir as an Islamic state but there are millions of other Muslims in Mesir who are not in favour to live in Mesir as an Islamic state.
These Muslims are ready to live in Mesir only when Mesir is a secular state. When Muhammad Mursi wanted to become the President who is having power above the laws, it causes many riots among the peoples of Mesir and even during this time, there were already voices in Mesir who wanted Muhammad Mursi to be removed from the office of the President of Mesir. Muhammad Mursi is a hafiz of Quran and an engineer but in my opinion, he is not a good politician. In my opinion the first action which should be taken by him as the first democratic President of Mesir, is to unite the whole Muslims in Mesir. When the whole Muslims in Mesir unite under him, then only he should introduce slowly the various actions which will finally establish Mesir as an Islamic state. In my opinion, the actions which were taken by Muhammad Mursi to establish Mesir as an Islamic state are a very drastic action. Muhammad Mursi should know that there are about 50% of the Muslims in Mesir who are not ready to live in Mesir as an Islamic state. In my opinion, the majority of the Muslims who are not the members of Muslims Brotherhood are opposed to the actions of Muhammad Mursi to establish Mesir as an Islamic state. In my opinion, the majority of the Muslims in Mesir was tired with the dictatorship rule of Gamal Nasir, Anwar Sadat and Hosni Mubarak and because of that they make a revolution to overthrow Hosni Mubarak. They overthrow Hosni Mubarak in order to have a regime change and not to have an Islamic state. The peoples of Mesir make revolution to overthrow Hosni Mubarak because they wanted to be ruled by a President who is elected by the peoples and not by a dictator that wanted to make Mesir an Islamic state.
In my opinion, the majority of the peoples of Mesir are not ready to be ruled by a President who wanted to make Mesir an Islamic state. Majority of the Muslims in Mesir wanted to be ruled by a President who is elected via the democratic system but they are not ready to be ruled by a President who wanted to make Mesir an Islamic state. Mesir was under the dictatorship of the armies for so many years and under the dictatorship of the armies, Mesir was a secular state which practices British laws and the majority of the peoples of Mesir are following British lifestyles. Muslims Brotherhood was established in 1920 and although it has been barred from entering politics for so many years, but it has many followers and sympathizers in Mesir. In a democratic system even the person who wins more than one vote than the others who have contested in the election will become the winner. Irrespective whether the person is capable or not capable of becoming the President of Mesir, the person who will become the President of Mesir is that person had won the election even by an extra of only one vote than the other candidates who had contested In the election. Muhammad Mursi becomes the President of Mesir when he had won 52 % of the votes while his next contender had won only 48% of the votes.
In other words, there are about 48% of the peoples of Mesir who were not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir. In case 48% who were not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir were able to accept the defeat, in my opinion, there will be no problems in Mesir. What is the reason which has led to the turmoil? The reason which has led to the turmoil in Mesir is the groups who were not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir were not able to accept their defeat in the general election. These groups probably are not aware of how the system of democracy works when electing a President. They are not aware of how the system of democracy works because in Mesir they were under the autocratic system for a very long time. In a democratic system, Muhammad Mursi should become the President of Mesir because he had won the Presidential election in Mesir. Muhammad Mursi had won the Presidential election because he had managed to gather about 52% of the votes. About 48% of the peoples in Mesir were not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir. These groups who were against Muhammad Mursi were not happy with the results of the election and were not willing to accept the result of the presidential election. These groups were finding ways on how to overthrow President Muhammad Mursi. What were the excuses which they were trying to give in order to justify their action to overthrow President Muhammad Mursi? They gave the excuses that Muhammad Mursi was overthrown because he was not capable to become the President of Mesir.
The excuses which they gave in order to overthrow Muhammad Mursi were not valid excuses. In my opinion, the real reason why they wanted to overthrow President Muhammad Mursi was because Muhammad Mursi wanted to make Mesir an Islamic state. About 48% of the peoples of Mesir are against Muhammad Mursi because they wanted Mesir to remain a secular state. In order to prevent Mesir from becoming an Islamic state, they wanted Muhammad Mursi to step down from becoming the President of Mesir. Since they know they are not able to make Muhammad Mursi to step down as the President of Mesir via the electoral boxes, they used the armed forces of Mesir to force Muhammad Mursi to step down from becoming the President of Mesir. Is this not a coup d’état? In my opinion the action of the arm forces of Mesir to force Muhammad Mursi to step down from becoming the President of Mesir was an act of coup d’état. Naturally the armed forces of Mesir belong to the 48% of the peoples who are not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir. In this case the armed forces of Mesir are willing to be used by the groups who are not in favour of Muhammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir to perform the coup d’état.
When the armed forces are willing to be used by the groups who also wanted the power to rule Mesir, the armed forces are actually dragging Mesir into a conflict or turmoil. The armed forces of Mesir have been used by the groups who also wanted the power to rule Mesir into making Mesir the land of turmoil. During the conflicts there were thousands of people who were killed by the armies. Who are the peoples who were being killed by the armies of Mesir? The peoples who were being killed by the armies of Mesir were the very peoples whom the armies of Mesir are supposed to protect them from the enemies of Mesir. Who are the real fools in the crisis? In my opinion the real fools in the crisis are the armies who have allowed the groups who also wanted the power to rule Mesir to use them in dragging Mesir into the land of turmoil. The groups who also wanted the power to rule Mesir have caused many deaths among the innocent publics and have caused endless political disturbances in Mesir. Many in the opinion, that the groups who also wanted the power to rule Mesir and who had caused turmoil in Mesir are the Americans and the Jews. In my opinion the groups who also wanted the power to rule Mesir and who had caused turmoil in Mesir are not the Americans and the Jews but the shrewd politicians of Mesir. In my opinion the armed forces of Mesir have been used by the shrewd politicians of Mesir to cause turmoil in Mesir. With the turmoil the shrewd politicians hope there will be a new general election in Mesir and with the new general election the shrewd politicians are aiming of gaining power to rule Mesir but through a very shrewd way.
What should be the responsibility of the armed forces of Mesir? The armed forces of Mesir should have obeyed the President of Mesir who is elected by the peoples and they should not allow themselves to be used by the groups who also wanted the power to rule Mesir in causing turmoil in Mesir. The armed forces of Mesir as well as the pious alone of Mesir should abstain themselves from mingling with the politic of Mesir. The armed forces and the pious alone of Mesir should be with the President of Mesir who is elected by the peoples. The armed forces should realize the fact that their main work is not to become the mediator in the political issues of Mesir but to protect the country against the intruders and the enemies of Mesir. The main work of the armed forces should be to maintain peace in Mesir and not to create chaos and turmoil in the country. Politic is not the expertise of the armed forces and when the armed forces started to meddle in political issues, it causes chaos and turmoil in Mesir. When there is chaos in the country then the work of the armed forces is no longer to protect the peoples of Mesir against the foreign intruders but to kill the peoples of Mesir. When the armed forces have started to take part in the politic of a country as it is now in Mesir, the country will certainly have chaos and turmoil instead of having peace and tranquility. What the armed forces are known to be good at? Are the armed forces good in ruling the country? Are the armed forces good in administering the country? Are the armed forces good at maintaining peace and stability in the country?
In my opinion the armed forces are good only in killing the enemies of the country. Will there be peace in countries where the armed forces are meddling with the politics of the country? In countries where the armies are meddling with the politics of the country there is no peace but only turmoil and backwardness. Is there any country in this world which is modern and progressive and is ruled by the armed forces? There is no country in this world which is modern and progressive which is ruled by the armed forces. The armies are not trained to rule the country and they are not trained to administer the country but they are trained only to fight the enemies of the country. When a person who is not having the capability to rule a country is made to rule a country then the country will not be moving towards progressiveness but will be moving towards backwardness and towards the path of turmoil and destruction. Mesir is now on the road toward turmoil and destruction because the armies who are not the expert in politics are trying to solve the political issues of Mesir. The armed forces of Mesir should realize that they are not capable of solving the political issues of Mesir and they should not have put their hand on political issues. Instead of the armed forces are solving the political issues of Mesir; they are making the political issues of Mesir to become even more complicated and sophisticated. In my opinion the armed forces of Mesir are very naïve. Because the armed forces are very naïve they were easily used by the shrewd politicians to drag Mesir into turmoil.
The shrewd politicians of Mesir were trying to use the armies in solving the political problems in Mesir. When the shrewd politicians were successful in persuading the armies to interfere with the political issues of Mesir, it means they were successful in creating chaos and anarchy in Mesir. When there are turmoil and anarchy in Mesir then there will be opportunity for them to gain power in Mesir. With the downfall of Hosni Mubarak the peoples of Mesir are forced to use the system of democracy in electing their President. When they are forced to use the system of democracy in electing their President, it means they are forced to allow anyone in Mesir to contest in the election in order to enable the person to become the President of Mesir. In my opinion the peoples of Mesir wanted to have a President who is not an autocratic leader and a President who belongs to all the communities and not a President who belong only to a certain community. However Muhammad Mursi belongs to the communities of Muslims Brotherhood. He used to become the President of Muslims Brotherhood of Mesir. Although he had resigned from becoming the members of the Muslims Brotherhood but the soul and the mind of Muhammad Mursi is still the soul and the mind of the Muslims Brotherhood of Mesir. The majority of the peoples of Mesir do not want their President to be the President or the members of the Muslims Brotherhood of Mesir but they want a President who belongs to all the peoples of Mesir. They fear if the President of Mesir belongs to Muslims Brotherhood, the President will certainly favour the members of the Muslims Brotherhood above others in Mesir. However Muslims Brotherhood has influenced over the political landscape of Mesir for nearly 100 years.
When a revolution sparked in Tunisia to overthrow the President of Tunisia, Muslims Brotherhood of Mesir took this opportunity to lead the peoples of Mesir on a similar revolution to overthrow Hosni Mubarak. The downfall of Hosni Mubarak had lead to the process of democracy to take place in Mesir in electing the President of Mesir. When the Presidential election was conducted in Mesir, Muhammad Mursi who was the member of the Muslims Brotherhood won the Presidential election. Muhammad Mursi was made the first President of Mesir who is elected by the peoples of Mesir. However there were about 48% of the peoples of Mesir who were not in favour of Mohammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir. The majority of those who were not in favour of Mohammad Mursi to become the President of Mesir are not the members of Muslims Brotherhood and this include the majority of the armed forces. Although Mohammad Mursi was the President of Mesir but the army of Mesir was not with him and the armed forces were not under the control of the President. In Mesir it seems the armed forces are allowed to make decisions on their own which mean the armed forces are not under the President of Mesir.
In Mesir it seems the armed forces are allowed to receive money directly from the United State of America. In my opinion, a system has been designed and implanted in Mesir in order to ensure the President is always under the control of the armed forces. It seems, a system has been designed in Mesir in order to ensure, the armed forces are always above the President. It seems, in Mesir the armed forces have been given the power which is similar to the power which are given to the King and the monarch of the world. In other words in Mesir, the armed forces have the ultimate power to decide on whom and who should become the President of Mesir. In my opinion, a system had been designed previously by the dictators of Mesir in order to ensure at all the time, Mesir is under the control of the armed forces and that the armed forces are always superior to the President and more powerful than the President of Mesir. In other word the President of Mesir is not under the control of the peoples of Mesir but under the control of the armed forces of Mesir. In my opinion, the system of democracy will never work in Mesir until the right to decide who should become the President of Mesir is taken away from the armed forces of Mesir and given back to the peoples of Mesir. As it is now, in Mesir it is not the peoples who decide who is to become the President of Mesir but the armed forces of Mesir is the one who has the ultimate power to decide who should become the President of Mesir.
Prof Dr Nasoha Saabin
December 2013
Integrative Holistic Wellness Centre